Baldwin provides a different insight into the role of economic power in the conduct of foreign policy. Michelsen institute cmi norway in cooperation with institute of. By underscoring the importance of interdependence and economic means in foreign policy, geoeconomics also resonates with ir liberalism. International law seeks to control the conduct of states. A nuclear world desperately in need of alternatives to military. In this book david baldwin draws on social power analyses to develop an analytic framework for evaluating such techniques, and uses it to challenge the conventional view that economic tools of foreign policy do not work. A political theory of economic statecraft article pdf available in foreign policy analysis 44. Power and international relations princeton university press. Since this grudging acquiescence has recently been confused with advocacy e. The effects and determinants of coercive economic statecraft, commodity certification programs, and sanctions chapter i. Geoeconomics, or economic statecraft, therefore combines the logic of geopolitics with the tools of economics, viewing the economic actions and options of a given state as embedded within larger realities of state power. At the power play end of economic diplomacy is what baldwin 1985 calls economic statecraft which is the strategic use of positive and negative economic sanctions such as trade embargoes as well as aid programs by states and other actors such as the united nations to coerce other states to cooperate see also davis 1999, hogan 1987. Foreign aid, trade, and policies governing the international flow of capital can be used as foreign policy tools and are considered the most common forms of economic statecraft. Economic sanctions reconsidered hufbauer, gary clyde, schott, jeffrey, elliott, kimberly ann, oegg, barbara on.
Even though it is hard to prove whether economic statecraft is useful in achieving ones goals or not, it is very commonly used baldwin 1985. Using economic policy to achieve foreign policy goals. Denying key resources or market opportunities harms the target state, while preferential access offers benefits. At the power play end of economic diplomacy is what baldwin 1985 calls economic statecraft, which is the strategic use of positive and negative economic sanctions such as trade embargoes as well as aid programs by states and other actors such as the united nations to coerce other states to cooperate see also hogan 1987. Here professor baldwin tears apart the reasoning of most other scholars and torpedoes not only the conventional wisdom about various cases but just about all. My core argument is that a countrys employment of geoeconomic instruments is not merely a function of its national interest, but also depends on its diplomats abilities of applying such instruments, which again is closely connected to the overall degree of independence be. In determining whether the episode was successful, we confine our examination to changes in the policies, capabilities or government of th e target country. Chinas economic statecraft series on contemporary china. Geoeconomics as concept and practice in international. Economic statecraft can be defined as the use of economic means to achieve foreign policy goals baldwin 1985.
Economic statecraft, the use of economic means to pursue foreign policy goals. Market reactions to regulations on conflict minerals from the democratic republic of the congo 1. His many books include economic statecraft princeton and paradoxes of power. The session on chinas economic power and major foreign policy issues focused on chinas use of economic statecraft in advancing sinou. Economic statecraft by david allen baldwin goodreads. Chinas positive economic statecraft in africa historical comparisons ana cristina alves paper presented at the international conference china and africa media, communications and public diplomacy organised by the chr. Economic statecraft, in the broad meaning given to the term by david baldwin, 1 could not as such be an object for international law analysis. Baldwin s economic statecraft, which set the agenda for the sanctions field during the 1980s, cites the hse study no fewer than 21 times. A nuclear world desperately in need of alternatives to military force demands better understanding of all techniques of statecraft.
As we show below, geoeconomics can contrib ute to ir realism by providing novel conceptual tools for analysing economic forms of power projection. By differentiating between ends and means, baldwin argues that economic statecraft refers to the type of policy instrument used, not the effect that it is intended to have. Economic diplomacy oxford research encyclopedia of. Baldwin is senior political scientist in the woodrow wilson school of public and international affairs at princeton university and the wallach professor of political science emeritus at columbia university. Political theory of economic statecraft foreign policy. Through an original application of the theoretical framework david baldwin has developed in economic statecraft, it is argued that the trade remedy laws utilize state power for the purpose of changing the behaviour, beliefs, policies and propensities to. The international law of economic statecraft in the east. One writer contends that recent international relations scholarship has promoted opti mism about the utility of such measures and sets out to challenge this trend. During the cold war, trade patterns closely reflected political relations e. The starting place for serious discussion of the use of economic power for political purposes is david baldwin s economic statecraft. Baldwin in the book with the same name represents economic policy.
Through an original application of the theoretical framework david baldwin has developed in economic statecraft, it is argued that the trade remedy laws utilize state power for the purpose of changing the behaviour, beliefs, policies and propensities to act of foreign governments or firms. David baldwins economic statecraft is one of our fields best efforts to understand the. It might be noted that baldwin s interpretation of what constitutes instrumental activity, while it is both more logical and more elegant than galtungs definition in pacificism, is nonetheless considerably at variance with that definition. Geoeconomics and statecraft by robert blackwill henry a. Economic statecraft dip 720 university of kentucky.
Basically, when a sender state attempts to influence a target state to. Baldwin is the founder of the research committee on political power of the international political. This is a study of economics as an instrument of politics, and quite a rigorous one. State control and the effects of foreign relations on. By using the term economic sanctions, i reluctantly acquiesce to sloppy common usage. Access to society journal content varies across our titles. David baldwin s aggressively scholarly book should become required reading for anyone making a serious study of economics as an instrument of. First, despite baldwin s 1985 observation that various forms of economic statecraft follow a similar logic and hirschmans 1980 assertion that economic incentives influence states because of the possibility they create for future economic sanctions, the existing literature treats economic sanctions and economic. The objective is to punish or reward another state for its policy position. Commercial actors, grand strategy and state control distinguishes between chinas economic diplomacy and its economic statecraft and, as the title suggests, focuses on the latter.
In coercive cooperation, martin calls it the invaluable data set p. Economic statecraft with chinese characteristics core. For a comparative assessment of the work of baldwin. Click download or read online button to get economic sanctions reconsidered history and current policy book now. Economic sanctions reconsidered history and current policy. Hufbauer and schott, economic sanctions reconsidered, p. Clifton morgan and others published the sanctions paradox. Rather than treating economic sanctions as tools of statecraft, pape defines them in terms of a particular strategy for using such tools pp. The united nations security council voted for economic sanctions twelve times in the 1990s. Economic statecraft is the comprehensive name for economic policy.
Blackwill and harris 2016, 24 economic statecraft is therefore about the question how to shape economic policies to. It begins with meticulous discussions of the means and ends of national policy and power, and the larger part of the book focuses on economic sanctions. Special attention will be paid to economic statecraft by the united states, china, and russia. A wideranging disquisition on the myriad symbolic and substantive ways sanctions can be used to advance the national interest, it is also grounded in practical sense. State control and the effects of foreign relations on bilateral trade. Pdf if one interprets chinas sizable rise in latin america as an. Economic statecraft and chinese economic coercion this chapter is intended to introduce the foundations of economic statecraft and coercion, look at the current literature that deals with chinas use of it and possible causes. The literature on economic statecraft suffers from two important limitations. The exercise of economic statecraft has distributional consequences both at home and abroad. That is why i have put what i call economic statecraft at the heart of our foreign policy agenda. Baldwin and the logic of choice debate over whether economic sanctions work is mired in a scholarly limbo.
Baldwin, economic statecraft 57princeton 1985 noting that it would be difficult to find any proposition in the international relations literature more widely accepted than those belittling the utility of economic techniques of statecraft. Suffice it to say that policy banks like exim often blend chinas. Economic statecraft, according to baldwin 1985, is a practice through which noneconomic means are achieved through economic means influence attempts relying primarily on resources which have a reasonable resemblance of a market price in terms of money p. David allen, 1936publication date 1985 topics international economic relations, international relations. International sanctions as international punishment. The economic structure of renegotiation and dispute resolution in the world trade organization. This book aims to study chinas economic statecraft in the contemporary era in a comprehensive manner. The study builds a theory of economic statecraft that provides an explanation of how states use firms to pursue their strategic goals. Understanding diplomacy in the 21st century1 stiftung.
885 210 914 539 525 1362 910 568 1041 316 657 791 1183 1317 597 1145 170 255 291 439 1088 1275 968 138 1512 1103 1323 1173 221 359 1224 183 831 590 462 825 1261 67 1319 439 1239